The Up Post

I always had my reservations about Pixar’s Up. To be perfectly honest, when I first saw the concept sketches and promotional art for the movie I had genuine worry that Pixar might have dropped the ball. With such strong entries in the stable like The Incredibles, Toy Story and the recent Wall.e, Up has a high bar to hurdle right out of the gate. Unfortunately I don’t quite think it cleared the post.

Up falls into the sub-category of less than stellar Pixar movies along side A Bugs Life and Cars. These are not bad movies, not by a long shot, but they just don’t blow me away like their other classmates do. Up honestly feels like it should have been a Pixar short, shown before a real entry to the prestigious library. The main character, the plot and the whole approach to the film seems like it could have been a 5 min charmer before a big film. It’s pretty much an atmospheric music video, stretched out over an hour and a half.

Visually it’s of Pixar caliber, and the animation is top notch. Pixar are the best of the best when it comes to CG animations and Up has all the polish and frills that we have come to expect from these guys over the years. The characters are rather charming and the pairing of the grumudgeny old Carl with the overly enthusiastic boy scout; Russell, works quite well. They are an odd-couple pairing that bring out the best in each other, which is quite enjoyable to watch. The movie is actually very morose at times and the back story on Carl is rather touching.

People where crying during a Pixar movie…that’s weird to me.

Once the heartbreak tapers off, the adventure begins and unfortunately after the adventure gets underway, sheer randomness takes hold and the movie starts to fall apart. Ok a guy ties balloons to his house to sail away on an adventure…yes that’s pretty weird, but these movies are allowed a fantastical element or two. But it’s when an army of talking dogs in biplanes, a chocolate obsessed, 15-foot rainbow toucan and an airship piloted by a madman join the mix this movie just felt too oddball to be taken seriously. On one hand our hearts are bleeding for a old man who wishes to fulfill a promise to a long lost love, and on the other we have to deal with a talking dog who wants to take an extinct bird prisoner. The randomness robs the movie of any real soul and we are left with a rather empty movie when the crazy-dust settles.

The scenery is fantastic, the modeling and animation are phenomenal and the main characters are rather endearing. However everything else is a soulless romp through randomness, and that ultimately hurts this movie.